ROSA Desktop Fresh NetworkManager zomes

ROSA Desktop Fresh R4 KDE review

Though KDE 4.13.3 is the version of that desktop environment that’s installed by default, KDE 4.14.1 is available from the KDE backports repository. This screenshot shows the default desktop showing a StackFolder of the home directory. Besides KLook, StackFolder is a feature of the ROSA KDE desktop that’s not available on the KDE editions of other distributions.
ROSA Desktop Fresh R4 StackFolder

And it comes with a very beautiful icon theme – the ROSA Theme.
ROSA Desktop Fresh R4 Dolphin

Click on any image of this gallery to view the other aspects of the ROSA Desktop Fresh R4 KDE desktop.

A beautifully-designed desktop OS means nothing if it doesn’t come with enough point-and-click, user-friendly and easy-to-use applications. And ROSA Desktop has a few of the best graphical applications. Foremost being ROSA Media Player. It is the default playing for all multimedia files, both local and online. One application, multiple tasks. And ROSA Media Player is miles better than Amarok for tasks that Amarok is designed for.

ROSA Media Player

ROSA Media Player playing a Youtube video

Another application that looks good is YouMagic. Youmagic is the Russian version of Skype/Rebtel. For a few roubles, you can get a free local number in several major cities of Russia, and in other countries too. I don’t know what the call-quality is like, but YouMagic has a better logo that Skype. Given that, like Skype, it is not Free Software, I wonder whether it also comes with its own share of backdoors.
YouMagic number

What I’m beginning to realize regarding RPM distributions like ROSA Desktop and Fedora is that, in terms of a new class of applications that are being written, they are almost becoming second class citizens. By that I mean that installation binaries for those applications are not released for RPM distributions out of the gate. Examples of applications that I’m referring to are Brackets and those I wrote about here and here.

For those applications that are available in the repository, RPMDrake is still the default application for installing them. That’s because ROSA Software Center, which is intended to replace it, is still not ready for prime time.
ROSA Desktop RPMDrake

And with access to free and non-free applications enabled out of the box, you can install proprietary applications just as easily as you can install Open Source applications using RPMDrake.
ROSA Desktop repo manager

By default, the firewall application is disabled, so that is one of the very first things you probably would want to enable after installation.
ROSA Desktop Fresh R4 Firewall

Shorewall is that firewall application. It failed to start when I tried to enable it. But it’s not just that it failed to start that bugged me, it’s the fact that the system required the passphrase that I used to encrypt the disk before it could even attempt to start it. This was on an installation on real hardware where I encrypted the root partition just to test out the root partition encryption feature.
ROSA Desktop Fresh shorewall firewall

From the error message, it seems that Shorewall failed to start because it does not support network zones, a feature that’s part of Plasma NM, the network connections manager. This screenshot shows Plasma NM’s connection settings. You probably couldn’t tell just by looking at it, but the Firewall zone combo box is empty.
ROSA Desktop Fresh Plasma NM

Since FirewallD is in the repository and knowing that it has support for network zones, I installed it and tried to start it. Though it started, the system still requested the disk encryption passphrase before it could start. That still doesn’t make sense to me because I don’t see the connection between starting a service and disk encryption (passphrase). I am writing this on a Fedora 20 KDE desktop with FirewallD enabled and disk encryption configured. The system never requests the disk encryption passphrase when systemctl is called to start a service.
ROSA Desktop Fresh firewalld

This screenshot shows FirewallD’s built-in network zones as they are listed in the Firewall zone combo box of Plasma NM.
ROSA Desktop Fresh Plasma NM zones

Unless there’s a peculiar reason the developers have for implementing disk encryption in such a manner that the system has to request the encryption passphrase before it can start a daemon, then I must say that ROSA Desktop Fresh R4 has a major bug. Make that two bugs. Counting the failure to decrypt an encrypted disk when a /boot/efi partition is configured (on a computer with UEFI firmware) as bug number one. By the way, I did verify that the system will require authentication with the disk encryption passphrase before any service can be started.

ROSA Desktop is a favorite distribution of mine, but tinkering with the disk encryption feature in order to support encryption of the root partition appears to have introduced a bug in the system. I think the word for that is regression. If you fancy this edition of ROSA Desktop and you have no intention of encrypting the target disk, the system should work just fine. But if you must (encrypt the disk), watch out!

Resources: The Release Notes, including download links to installation images of ROSA Desktop Fresh R4, are available here.

Please share:

4 Responses

Leave a Reply to Steve Nordquist Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *