Partner links

Linux Mint 16 “Petra” Cinnamon, KDE and MATE review

Zemanta Related Posts Thumbnail

Security Posture: With full disk encryption and user account (home folder) encryption supported during the installation process, Linux Mint has almost all you need to provide top-notch physical security for your computer. The only missing feature is boot loader password protection. If you can apply the “nuclear option” (nuke) patch to LUKS cryptsetup that was just released and integrated into the latest edition of Kali Linux, it gets even better. (See A Kali Linux cryptsetup patch that can “nuke” an encrypted disk.)

Regarding network security, the firewall application called the Uncomplicated Firewall (ufw) is installed, but not enabled. Though network security goes beyond just enabling a firewall, it makes a difference, especially on an OS of this sort, to have a firewall enabled by default. Not everybody agrees with this stance, but I’m yet to have someone offer a good argument why having a firewall enabled by default is a bad idea.

There is a graphical interface to ufw that’s in the repository, but not installed on the Cinnamon and MATE editions. On the KDE edition, a firewall module for System Settings is installed, but not enabled. This screen shot shows it main interface in the default state. Aside from ufw, a better firewall application called FirewallD is in the repository. It’s what I have protecting a laptop running Linux Mint 15 Cinnamon. I’ve not installed it on any edition of Linux Mint 16, but I’m sure there should be no problem doing that. See How to replace Ufw with Firewalld in Linux Mint 15 if you want to see how to install it on your copy of Linux Mint 16.
Linux Mint 16 KDE Firewall

Games: Another feature all editions of Linux Mint (16) have in common, is the absence of games in the default installations. Not even a simple card game is installed. It’s almost as if the distribution’s developers have something against games. I’m sure that’s not the case, but… In any case, there are lots of games in the repository that can be installed using any one of the installed graphical package managers or from the command line.

They Just Work: For new users, and even for experienced users, the most important feature that all editions of Linux Mint 16 have in common is this: They just work. Just install a system and start being productive out of the gate. All the multimedia codecs you’ll need are installed. Connect a printer to the system and it’s configured automatically. You don’t even have to do anything. Just connect and print. That’s why the distribution is one of the most popular Linux desktop distributions in active development. It just works!

The Cinnamon Desktop: The Cinnamon desktop environment is a project started and maintained by the developers of Linux Mint, so you know you’ll always get the latest and greatest version here. For the record, the version you get is the Cinnamon 2.0.14. This desktop is a modern, anti-GNOME Shell desktop, designed to offer the same look and feel as older desktop environments like MATE, but built using modern technologies. It is currently built atop GNOME 3 technologies, but there are plans to go in a different direction in the future.

Cinnamon comes with a wide variety of graphical management utilities, so users rarely need to use the command line to accomplish any system management tasks. This screen shot shows the top section of the edition’s System Setting.
Cinnamon System Settings

This is the other half of Cinnamon’s System Settings.
Linux Mint 16 Cinnamon System Settings

The six images in this gallery, all with detailed descriptions, show different aspects of the Cinnamon desktop on Linux Mint 16.

The KDE Desktop: The KDE edition comes with KDE 4.11.2. Applying the latest updates bumps it to version 4.11.3. It uses the beautiful Oxymentary icon theme, which is almost as polished as the ROSA icon theme used on all editions of ROSA Desktop. Recommended disk space for the KDE desktop is 8.4 GB, though a new installation takes up just under 4.5 GB of disk space.

Like the Cinnamon desktop, KDE also has a control center that offers access to graphical applications that can be used for managing different aspects of the desktop. This screen shot shows a partial view of the applications.
Linux Mint 16 KDE System Settings

This gallery show aspects of the KDE desktop on Linux Mint 16. Click on any image to view it.

The MATE Desktop: The minimum disk space recommended for a fresh installation of the MATE edition is 8.1 GB, though a fresh installation takes up just under 4 GB of disk space. I’m not a fan of MATE, not because it’s not a good desktop environment, but simply because it’s old technology. This screen shot shows the control center.
Linux Mint 16 MATE Settings

Click on any image in this gallery to view different aspects of the MATE desktop on Linux Mint 16.

To sum, Linux Mint is one of those distributions that’s a joy to use and review. If you are new to Linux, this is one of the very best that we have and it gets better with each edition. If you want my opinion of which edition to use, you can’t go wrong with the Cinnamon edition. Regardless of the edition you use, just watch out for a crashing Software Manager.

Resources: You may download a 32- or 64-bit installation image of Linux Mint 16 Cinnamon, KDE and MATE editions from here. Though not featured in this review, there is also an Xfce edition which also available for download from that download page.



Partner links

Newsletter: Subscribe for updates

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
9 years ago

I started this journey with mate 15 when windows XP lost support mate revitalized a 9 year old machine it works great and on my other newer machine i now use the newer mate 17 for me mate was easer on the transition from xp to the Linux OS.

10 years ago

Good review … but yet another one where the reviewer doesn’t like the MATE desktop.

For those who don’t want fancy effects, it’s configurable, traditional, comfortable, and fairly lean (about the same as the less feature-rich XFCE and LXDE – yes, really)

Frank Clough
Frank Clough
10 years ago

Half a year ago I got really fed up with Windows and decided to give Linux a spin. I tried Fedora and after fiddling around with something impenetrable called Gnome for a while and getting nowhere I decided to install KDE. After jumping through hoops I finally got KDE to install and it was OK as a desktop, but the eternal fiddliness of Fedora, especially trying to install display drivers as well as other things that I just couldn’t get to work, very nearly made me give up on Linux forever.

Before I did give up I decided that as one last try I would take a look at this Linux Mint that I had read such good things about.

I have never looked back, Mint Cinnamon is now my OS of choice. It installed beautifully, it works perfectly with no fiddliness and is very easy for an ex-Windows user get used to. The perfect beginners Linux, and, I suspect, the perfect veterans Linux as well. It just does what an OS should do and it does it very well.

If any newbies ask about Linux you would be doing them a great disservice if you said anything other than “Mint 16 Petra.”

Reply to  Frank Clough
10 years ago

Agree. Cinnamon is the ideal desktop for users switching from Windows. It is simple, elegant and yet powerful. Only gripe is that applets / desklets need much more love. I am seeing progress there as well with lot of third party developers jumping and developing nifty tools.

10 years ago

I know that linux mint is a popular distribution.
Now and then I give it a try to see what’s all the fuss. Invariably I end up uninstalling mint.
Tried the Petra KDE version and once more it has been uninstalled. I find it is still rough around the edges when it comes to KDE…. I have tried other DE’s but I really enjoy KDE.
With Petra connecting my android phone to transfer files can only be done with dolphin, let me tell you this is quite a pain.
I’m sure there are hacks and incantations to be used, but I like the “just works” approach.
My distro of choice is still Opensuse KDE (13.1 as at todday)

Reply to  henry
10 years ago

Agree on the issue that Dolphin, by default, does not recognize Android devices. But you just need to install kio-mtp, no tricks involved.

I switched from KDE to Cinnamon and glad to say that I made the switch. it just works for me. (Am on Mint Box 2 PC)

Reply to  Anand
9 years ago

hey i hv heard lot about mint box .. so how is the performance ???..
i have heard someone saying it heats up a lot.
is it true??

Get the latest

On social media

Security distros

Linux distros for hacking and pentesting

Crypto mining OS

Distros for mining bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies

Crypto hardware

MSI GeForce GTX 1070
Installing Nvidia GTX 1070 GPU drivers on Ubuntu

Disk guide

Beginner's guide to disks & disk partitions in Linux

Bash guide

Bash shell terminal
How to set the PATH variable in Bash
Hya, what do you think? Please comment.x