Why free software shouldn’t depend on Mono or C#

by Richard M. Stallman

Debian’s decision to include Mono in its principal way of installing GNOME, for the sake of Tomboy which is an application written in C#, leads the community in a risky direction. It is dangerous to depend on C#, so we need to discourage its use.

The problem is not unique to Mono; any free implementation of C# would raise the same issue. The danger is that Microsoft is probably planning to force all free C# implementations underground some day using software patents. (See http://swpat.org and http://progfree.org.) This is a serious danger, and only fools would ignore it until the day it actually happens. We need to take precautions now to protect ourselves from this future danger.

This is not to say that implementing C# is a bad thing. Free C# implementations permit users to run their C# programs on free platforms, which is good. (The GNU Project has an implementation of C# also, called Portable.NET.) Ideally we want to provide free implementations for all languages that programmers have used.

The problem is not in the C# implementations, but rather in Tomboy and other applications written in C#. If we lose the use of C#, we will lose them too. That doesn’t make them unethical, but it means that writing them and using them is taking a gratuitous risk.

We should systematically arrange to depend on the free C# implementations as little as possible. In other words, we should discourage people from writing programs in C#. Therefore, we should not include C# implementations in the default installation of GNU/Linux distributions or in their principal ways of installing GNOME, and we should distribute and recommend non-C# applications rather than comparable C# applications whenever possible.

An earlier version of this article incorrectly stated that Mono would now be installed by default in Debian. We have corrected this text, and we are sorry for the error.

This article was originally published on the Free Software Foundation’s website.

Related Posts

Why I Will Not Sign the Public Domain Manifesto By Richard M. Stallman: The Public Domain Manifesto (http://www.publicdomainmanifesto.org/node/8) has its heart in the right place as it objects to so...
Google Superbowl Ad Explains The Need for Search Privacy Google's ad during yesterday's Superbowl explained in less than a minute how the story of someone's life can be pieced together from their search quer...
A Bill of Privacy Rights for Social Network Users Social network service providers today are in a unique position. They are intermediaries and hosts to our communications, conversations and connection...
Privacy Risks from Geographic Information In today's world more geographic information is being collected about us, such as where we live, where the clinic we visited is located, and where we ...
FreeBSD and the GPL Linus Torvalds has said Linux wouldn't have happened if 386BSD had been around when he started up. We trace the history of FreeBSD and how it's affect...
The Multiple Meanings of the Term “Open” Over the last couple of months I’ve found myself involved, both actively and passively, in several conversations that contained terms like “open” or “...

We Recommend These Vendors

Launch an SSD VPS in Europe, USA, Asia & Australia on Vultr's KVM-based Cloud platform starting at $5:00/month (15 GB SSD, 768 MB of RAM).

Deploy an SSD Cloud server in 55 seconds on DigitalOcean. Built for developers and starting at $5:00/month (20 GB SSD, 512 MB of RAM).


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*